Who would you rather work with?


Some of you may have already seen this story from Seth Godin, but it begs the question: “Who would you rather work with?”    

A small island grows sugar cane. Many people harvest it, and one guy owns the machine that can process the cane and turn it into juice.    

Who wins?   

Sugar Cane Machine

The guy with the machine, of course. It gives him leverage, and since he’s the only one, he can pay the pickers whatever he likes–people will either sell it to him or stop picking. No fun being the cane picker. He can also charge whatever he likes to the people who need the cane juice, because without him, there’s no juice. No fun being a baker or cook. But now, a second machine comes to the island, and then three more. There are five processors.    

Now who wins?    

Certainly not the guy with the first machine.  He has competitors for the cane. He can optimize and work on efficiency, but pretty soon he’s going to be in a price war for his raw materials (and a price war for the finished product).  Not so much fun to be the factory owner.  And then!  And then one cane processor starts creating a series of collectible containers, starts interacting with his customers and providing them with custom blends, starts offering long-term contracts and benefits to his biggest customers, and yes, even begins to pay his growers more if they’re willing to bring him particularly sweet and organic materials, on time.  In short, he becomes a master of the art of processing and marketing cane.  He earns permission, he treats different people differently and he refuses to act like a faceless factory…    

Who are you?  Who are we?      

Obviously we don’t work in the sugar industry, but we think the principle of treating people differently applies. We know there are many choices of who to work with, and we respect that and try to be different.  How can we be better?    


About the Author:  Aaron lives in Milwaukee, WI with his wife and two children and is the President & CEO of Clear Medical Solutions.  When he’s not leading new initiatives, he periodically takes on interim leadership or consulting projects.  He also enjoys teaching, speaking, writing, and sharing his passion for people and their healthcare.

Published by Aaron Biebert

I'm a director, film/video exec producer, leader & 8pm Warrior. I am passionately chasing my goals at all times. I'm listening. Let's talk!

One comment on “Who would you rather work with?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.